
International trade professionals often discuss market readiness, new opportunities, and partnerships when expanding into foreign markets. However, the judgment behind their advice can make a significant difference. The Certified International Trade Professional (CITP) designation requires professionals to agree to abide by the CITP Standards of Ethical Conduct annually.
Two key principles in these standards are competency and integrity. Ethical decisions in international trade are not limited to multinational corporations or large-scale bribery and corruption cases. A case in point is Yucatan Foods, which paid approximately $14,000 in bribes to obtain a wastewater discharge permit in Mexico.
Competency and Integrity in International Trade
This case highlights the importance of recognizing that competency without integrity is not ethical professional practice, and vice versa. A knowledgeable trade professional may understand foreign-market regulations and customs procedures, but that expertise can be misused if not accompanied by integrity.
On the other hand, integrity without competency can also cause harm. For instance, a consultant may be honest and enthusiastic but lack the experience to recognize important import restrictions or misunderstand the true landed cost of a product. This can lead to costly decisions for clients who trust the advice.
Recognizing the limits of one’s competency is not a weakness but rather part of exercising integrity. This means being honest about the risks and limitations of one’s advice and being prepared to question a decision, even if it’s inconvenient or unpopular.
Pressures and Responsibilities
These principles apply not only to independent consultants but also to trade professionals working within organizations. They must identify and explain risks, communicate them honestly, and acknowledge the need for additional training or professional development when necessary.
A well-intentioned employee may be asked to assess a complex issue beyond their area of expertise. Acting ethically may mean investing in proper market research and data or bringing in outside expertise before making a recommendation. Good advice sometimes requires additional investment, whether in people, knowledge, or information.
Before making a decision, international trade professionals should consider two important factors: their competency to provide advice or make a decision, and whether they are exercising that competency with integrity. Neither factor is sufficient on its own; both must be considered.
The CITP Standards of Ethical Conduct provide a foundation for considering these factors and for ethical professional practice. Renewing an ethical commitment every year, as required by FITT, serves as a reminder that neither competency nor integrity can be taken for granted.
A professional designation speaks to what one knows, but conduct demonstrates how that knowledge is used. Whether independent advisors, employees, or leaders in public and private organizations, ethical professional practice requires both competency and integrity, and FITT requires CITPs to complete an annual ethics attestation.
One key aspect of the CITP Standards of Ethical Conduct is the emphasis on responsibility to clients or employers, the profession, and the public.
Exercising Integrity in International Trade
In the FITTskills courses, we examine how to find and vet intermediaries and channel partners, including the benefits and risks of these relationships. One important consideration is that businesses can be held accountable for the actions of agents, representatives, and other third parties acting on their behalf. Simply saying “we didn’t know” doesn’t make the problem go away. Understanding who represents your business, how they operate, and what they’re doing on your behalf is part of doing business internationally.